(EDITOR’S NOTE: View From The Pugh is a journalism project from Chris Pugh. Subscribe to his daily newsletter and podcast, follow him on YouTube and sponsor his work)
Today’s post is sponsored by StreamYard.
In February 2013, the Carnival Triumph set out for a routine four-day voyage in the Gulf of Mexico. What passengers got instead was an experience that would be remembered for all the wrong reasons — and dubbed by the media as the “Poop Cruise.”
After an engine fire knocked out the ship’s power, the Triumph drifted helplessly with over 4,000 passengers and crew on board. The lack of power quickly turned into a full-scale disaster. Toilets stopped working, sewage overflowed into hallways, and passengers were instructed to use red biohazard bags for waste disposal.
As conditions deteriorated, crew members tried to manage the chaos the only way they could: with morale-boosting tactics. That included a questionable decision to offer free alcohol — which only led to more chaos, including fights, public indecency, and scenes that one passenger likened to a “floating Lord of the Flies.”
While no lives were lost, the Carnival Triumph episode remains one of the most shocking — and oddly humorous — maritime disasters of the past few decades. Unlike the Titanic, which is remembered with reverence, the Triumph became a punchline.
But the conversation doesn't stop at sewage and sea sickness. We also take a humorous look at whether this disaster could somehow be repackaged. Could Carnival lean into the notoriety and create a “Poop Cruise Night” experience for the morbidly curious? Could passengers who survived wear it like a badge of honor?
That raises ethical questions, of course. Can you market a bad experience? Should you?
In contrast, the Titanic has been romanticized for over a century, thanks to blockbuster films and sweeping historical narratives. But maybe there’s something uniquely modern — and strangely human — about the Poop Cruise. After all, this wasn’t an iceberg or freak wave. This was a mess of our own making: mechanical failure, corporate underreaction, and a human instinct to party through the apocalypse.
In the end, the Carnival Triumph incident isn’t just a story of a cruise gone wrong — it’s a case study in crisis management, customer expectations, and how quickly things can unravel when the plumbing goes offline.
Would we recommend going on a cruise? Sure — just maybe not with Carnival. And definitely not if they hand you a red bag.
Comments
Post a Comment