A legacy sequel: Revisiting 'I Know What You Did Last Summer'

(EDITOR’S NOTE: ⁠View From The Pugh⁠ is a journalism project from ⁠Chris Pugh⁠. ⁠Subscribe to his daily newsletter⁠ and ⁠podcast⁠, ⁠follow him on YouTube⁠ and ⁠sponsor his work⁠)

Today’s post is sponsored by ⁠StreamYard⁠.

In 1997, I Know What You Did Last Summer carved its place in horror history. Riding the wave of Scream-inspired slashers, the film blended glossy teen drama with edge-of-your-seat suspense. Its hook-wielding killer, fisherman’s slicker, and a cast of rising stars—Jennifer Love Hewitt, Freddie Prinze Jr., Sarah Michelle Gellar, and Ryan Phillippe—captured the essence of late-90s horror.

Now, more than two decades later, the fisherman is back. The upcoming legacy sequel promises a fresh coat of blood while honoring the original’s legacy. Legacy sequels—films that bridge original stories with new narratives—have become a staple in Hollywood, offering nostalgia to long-time fans while reeling in new audiences.

The new chapter reportedly brings back Hewitt and Prinze Jr., reprising their roles as Julie James and Ray Bronson. While plot details remain under wraps, early reports hint at a blend of old rivalries, unresolved trauma, and a new generation of characters caught in a deadly game. This formula mirrors other recent horror revivals like Halloween (2018) and Scream (2022), which leaned heavily on emotional continuity and thematic resonance.

The original film was more than just a slasher—it was a cultural snapshot. It tapped into fears of guilt, secrecy, and how one split-second decision can haunt a lifetime. The sequel’s challenge will be balancing fan service with innovation. Over-relying on callbacks could alienate newcomers, while ignoring the original’s tone risks losing what made it iconic.

Fans will be watching closely for how the film handles its killer. Will the fisherman return unchanged, or will the legend evolve with new motives? And in a post-social media age, could the “I know what you did” message take on an even more sinister, public form?

Legacy sequels thrive when they respect their source material but dare to surprise. If done well, this return to I Know What You Did Last Summer could both honor its place in horror history and carve out a new legacy for the next generation of scream queens and final boys. Until then, we’ll be keeping an eye out for that ominous note and the shadow of a slicker in the mist.