(EDITOR’S NOTE: View From The Pugh is a journalism project from Chris Pugh. Subscribe to his daily newsletter and podcast, follow him on YouTube and sponsor his work)
Today’s post is sponsored by StreamYard.
When NBC announces a new workplace sitcom, expectations are inevitable. But when that sitcom is already drawing comparisons to The Office—arguably one of the most beloved comedies of the 21st century—the bar gets set sky-high. That’s exactly the challenge facing The Paper, NBC’s upcoming series about the chaotic, quirky staff of a struggling city newspaper.
It’s not hard to see why people are making the comparison. Like The Office, The Paper promises an ensemble cast of eccentric characters, everyday workplace drama, and a mix of sharp humor and awkward moments. But while The Office thrived in a fictional paper company, The Paper will dive into the fast-paced, deadline-driven world of journalism. The difference in setting could give the show a unique flavor—especially in an era when the news industry itself is full of real-world tension and absurdity.
So what will it take for The Paper to stand on its own while appealing to The Office’s loyal fanbase?
1. A Distinct Tone and Style
The worst thing The Paper could do is feel like a recycled version of The Office. Fans are expecting fresh storylines, a different comedic rhythm, and maybe even a new visual style. While mockumentary-style filming worked wonders for The Office, The Paper may opt for a more cinematic approach—or find its own inventive twist on the format.
2. Characters That Stick
The Office became legendary largely because of its characters—Michael Scott, Jim, Pam, Dwight, and an entire supporting cast who felt real, flawed, and lovable. For The Paper, creating distinct, memorable personalities will be essential. Early casting news suggests a mix of comedic veterans and rising stars, which could help establish instant chemistry.
3. Balancing Humor with Heart
The magic of The Office wasn’t just the jokes—it was the humanity behind them. Relationships, personal struggles, and moments of unexpected warmth made the laughs land harder. If The Paper can combine newsroom chaos with emotional beats, it has a shot at building lasting appeal.
4. Commentary on Modern Work Life
Journalism is changing rapidly, and The Paper could use its premise to satirize everything from clickbait culture to corporate takeovers. A fresh, timely perspective could keep it relevant in ways The Office—rooted in early-2000s office culture—couldn’t be.
Of course, comparisons to The Office are both a blessing and a curse. On one hand, they bring immediate attention and curiosity. On the other, they set impossible expectations. Fans who expect another Michael Scott or Jim and Pam dynamic might be disappointed if the show takes a different direction. But if The Paper leans into its own identity, it has the potential to be more than “the next Office”—it could be the first Paper.
In the end, whether The Paper lives up to The Office’s legacy will depend on its willingness to take risks, trust its cast, and create a workplace that feels as authentic as it is hilarious. And if it can deliver those watercooler-worthy moments, NBC might just have its next comedy classic.
Comments
Post a Comment