(EDITOR’S NOTE: View From The Pugh is a journalism project from Chris Pugh. Subscribe to his daily newsletter and podcast, follow him on YouTube and sponsor his work)
Today’s post is sponsored by StreamYard.
From Top 10 of All Time countdowns to a critic’s annual Best of the Year picks, movie lists are everywhere. They dominate entertainment websites, flood YouTube videos, and circulate endlessly on social media. But with every new ranking comes something inevitable — the debate.
Whether it’s arguing about which movies made the cut, which ones were “snubbed,” or why a particular film ranks so high (or low), these lists stir passionate conversations. But why do they provoke such strong reactions? The answer lies in the subjective nature of movies themselves.
Personal Taste and Emotional Connection
Movies aren’t just entertainment — they’re personal experiences. Your favorite film may be tied to a specific time in your life, a memory with friends or family, or even a personal milestone. For someone else, that same movie might be unremarkable or even disliked.
When a “best movies” list leaves off a film you love, it can feel like your tastes — and by extension, your experiences — are being dismissed. This is why disagreements over rankings often feel more like personal disputes than objective conversations.
Cultural Context and Perspective
A film’s impact isn’t universal; it’s influenced by culture, upbringing, and exposure. A critic raised on classic Hollywood cinema might revere Casablanca or Citizen Kane, while a younger moviegoer may find more resonance in Parasite or Everything Everywhere All at Once.
Lists reflect the background and biases of their creators. That’s why an American “Top 10” list might differ greatly from a European one — and why debates across cultures can be so eye-opening (and sometimes so heated).
Generational Differences
Every generation has its cinematic touchstones. Baby Boomers may gravitate toward The Godfather or Lawrence of Arabia, Gen X might champion Pulp Fiction or Fight Club, and Millennials or Gen Z might hold The Social Network or Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse in equally high regard.
When lists mix these eras together, fans often argue about what should be considered “great” — timeless classics, or modern breakthroughs? The answer depends entirely on who you ask.
The Influence of Critics and Gatekeepers
Critics, film festivals, and award shows shape the conversation around movies. A critic’s personal bias can influence rankings just as much as audience polls. When “best movies” lists come from respected outlets like Sight & Sound or AFI, they can feel authoritative — but they’re still shaped by subjective choices.
For some, these lists validate their tastes. For others, they become a target for criticism, especially if they overlook fan favorites or prioritize “artistic” films over crowd-pleasers.
The Role of Social Media in Amplifying Debate
In the pre-internet era, disagreements over movie lists might have stayed within friend groups or film clubs. Today, social media allows anyone to share their rankings — and just as quickly, allows others to challenge them.
Platforms like Twitter, Reddit, and YouTube thrive on hot takes, and debating movie lists is a perfect storm for engagement. Disagreement isn’t just inevitable; it’s encouraged.
Why the Debate Is a Good Thing
While it’s easy to roll your eyes at yet another “Best of” list, these debates are part of what makes film culture vibrant. Lists encourage people to share their favorites, discover overlooked gems, and think critically about what makes a movie “great.”
Disagreement forces us to examine why we value certain films over others — and in doing so, we learn more about cinema and about ourselves.
Final Take
Movie lists will never be universally agreed upon — and that’s the point. They’re conversation starters, cultural snapshots, and invitations to explore new stories. The next time a list leaves out your favorite film, take it as an opportunity: not to be frustrated, but to share your own ranking and keep the debate alive.
Because in the end, the real magic isn’t in the list — it’s in the conversation it sparks.
Comments
Post a Comment