(EDITOR’S NOTE: View From The Pugh is a journalism project from Chris Pugh. Subscribe to his daily newsletter and podcast, follow him on YouTube and sponsor his work)
Today’s post is sponsored by StreamYard.
Contract negotiations for Pittsburgh Steelers star TJ Watt could become one of the most debated topics in the NFL. With another top defender recently signing a lucrative deal, some believe Watt should command a similar—or even higher—salary. However, not everyone is convinced the Steelers will make that kind of financial commitment.
Is Watt worth $45 million per year, or should Pittsburgh take a wait-and-see approach before making such a massive investment?
Speaker 2: The Steelers Won’t Offer $45 Million—Yet
Recent contract deals in the NFL have shifted the market for elite pass rushers. While TJ Watt is undoubtedly one of the best defenders in the league, Speaker 2 argues that Pittsburgh is unlikely to hand out a $45 million annual salary right away.
The primary reason? The team needs to assess its overall roster situation, particularly at quarterback. If the Steelers continue to struggle offensively and fail to compete for the playoffs, allocating such a large portion of the salary cap to one player could limit future flexibility.
While Watt’s impact is undeniable, Pittsburgh may be cautious and wait before restructuring or extending his deal.
Speaker 1: The Financial Risk of a Losing Season
If the Steelers underperform and fail to find stability at quarterback, the team could be staring at a losing season. In that case, committing such a high salary to Watt could be risky.
With a below .500 record, Pittsburgh would need to rebuild key parts of its roster. Speaker 1 argues that handing Watt a record-breaking contract might not be the best long-term decision if the team isn’t contending for a championship.
Speaker 2: Watt Wins Games—Unlike Garrett
While some teams hesitate to pay defensive stars record-breaking money, Speaker 2 makes a compelling argument—Watt is a game-changer. Unlike Myles Garrett, who plays at a high level but hasn’t consistently delivered in big moments, Watt has a track record of making game-winning plays.
His ability to create turnovers, disrupt offenses, and lead the Steelers’ defense gives him immense value. If Pittsburgh wants to remain competitive in a tough AFC, locking up their best player is a must.
Should the Steelers Make the Move?
The debate ultimately comes down to Pittsburgh’s priorities. If the team believes it is one or two pieces away from serious contention, extending Watt at $45 million per year could be a justifiable investment. However, if the Steelers are in rebuilding mode, they may need to be more cautious with long-term financial commitments.
One thing is certain—Watt’s value to the franchise is undeniable. Whether the Steelers pay him now or later, he remains the heart and soul of their defense.
🚨 Key Questions:
💰 Is Watt worth $45 million per year?
📉 Would a losing season make this contract a mistake?
🔄 How does this compare to other NFL contracts?
TJ Watt has been the backbone of the Steelers’ defense, making game-changing plays and leading Pittsburgh to key victories. But with the team’s offensive future uncertain, should the Steelers commit to such a massive contract now, or take a more cautious approach?
💬 What’s your take? Should Pittsburgh pay Watt or wait? Drop your thoughts in the comments!
👍 LIKE, COMMENT & SUBSCRIBE for More NFL Talk!
- #SteelersNation, #TJWatt, #NFLContracts, #PittsburghSteelers, #NFLNews, #NFLDebate, #SteelersFootball, #FootballTalk, #SteelersDefense, #MylesGarrett, #NFLMoneyTalk, #SteelCurtain, #NFLPredictions, #NFL2025, #FootballFans, #NFLSalaryCap, #ContractDebate, #SportsDebate, #NFLHotTakes, #TJWattHighlights, #PittsburghSports, #NFLAnalysis, #DefensivePlayerOfTheYear, #PassRushers, #SteelersUpdates
Comments
Post a Comment